Geofish Mexico Review

GEOFISH Trailer from MOTIV FISHING on Vimeo.


Ok, ok. It’s finally been done. Finally. This is probably the first (and only) really great fly fishing video I’ve seen. At last, someone has got it right.

If that sounds harsh to all the other production crews and fly-anglers-come-videographers out there, well, let’s just review. We had the Trout Bum Diaries produced by the now extinct Angling Exploration Group (AEG, which has actually been re-invented in the Geofish series, but more on that later). These films were OK,  certainly better than what was around at the time, but they still didn’t really get it. Mostly it was a bunch of guys who wanted to go fishing and maybe use the video as an excuse to get sponsorship to fulfill an angling dream. Good for them. Clever. However, it was pretty obvious that no one wanted to hold the camera. So what we got was a jumbled story-line, incomplete fishing sequences, and a final Smörgåsbord of dripping fish to finish the movie off.

Saltwater videos have done no better. The dudes that did The Search: Tahiti made a good start of it, but also had an aversion to actually holding anything so mundane as a camera when bonefish were around. As a result the film falls flat.

I mean, it’s not a complicated formula. If you set up the journey/quest by saying, “We’re off to [insert exotic destination here] to see if we can catch trophy [insert species here] on our own”, then you’ve got to get the shot. Simple.

However, film after film left us hanging. Bonefish: A Fishing Odyssey was another that started well but failed to capture the final shot. There was simply no pay-off for the weeks of searching for the elusive double-digit bonefish. Sure, there was some shaky footage at the end where Mr. Rangely-Wilson is holding a so-called 10-pounder (and since he was there and we weren’t, he’s got the benefit of the doubt) but we don’t really see it. What we get is some shaking hand-held footage of a bonefish release. No hookup, no fight, nothing.

But these were all done by amateurs, anglers that set themselves a quest and either accomplished it or didn’t. You’d think that professional guides with nearly endless time on the water could do better, but no. Not so much. Black Tailed Devils was awesome in trailer form but the actual feature film was just horrible. Save your money on that one.

A major exception was In Search of a Rising Tide, which features a couple Bahamian guides on a “day off.” Of course, it’s filmed and produced by Howard Films, and these are guys who know how to get the shot. I remember reading an interview with the videographer where he said he refuses to combine fishing and filming, because he’ll either miss the fish, or miss the shot, or, more likely, both. The man is dropping knowledge, and it paid off. For me this short film is pretty much a cult classic for anyone interested in trophy bonefish on the fly. But, it’s a somewhat different set-up. It’s not so much about a journey or quest as it is about the history of Bahamian bonefishing. It’s a glimpse into the life of the younger generation of guides that have taken the sport of bonefishing with a flyrod to the next level. Being on board with Andy Smith and “Big” Charlie Neymour as they cast flies at bonefish is a relaxing, almost comforting experience, not the nerve-wracking trek the boys from Geofish set themselves.

So, back to that. I can personally attest that their first installment, Geofish Mexico, really does capture the same sense of a wild adventure that you see in the above trailer, and they do it by sticking to the script. First, there’s the set-up: four friends (which, weirdly, includes some of the original Trout Bum players) have the idea to travel from the Pacific Northwest down to the tip of South America, by driving… and, of course, fish like hell along the way. But, this time there’s no rush to get to the fishing action. The first half of the film is dedicated to the journey, and the first half of that first half is them simply trying to get the truck they bought to actually work on recycled frier oil. There are some truly classic scenes here. Think A-Team if the dudes from Top Gear were in charge: ambitious, but rubbish. By the time we do actually get to some fishing you can seriously empathize with the guys on-screen who’ve been waiting much longer than you have. Basically, they get you into the story by mimicking—on a smaller scale—the frustrating wait they had themselves. This is a case of giving the audience what they need, not what they want, and in this world of short attention spans and 30-second film bytes, I applaud them for this. Of course, it’s also simply good story-telling.

In the end that’s what this first film is: a great story, well told. I could go on, but I won’t. Buy a copy now! You’ll thank me later.

Sitting down to watch it again,
WindKnot the (jealous) Angler

Share :
Related Posts
  • Reply

    I loved that someone finally showed the hard work and trials that go in to pulling off a fishing trip. I was starting to feel like I was the only one that struggled to get out of the driveway to go fish, even just down the road. “Did I remember to grab (insert anything necessary for a fishing excursion here)?” haha

    There were some editing details I wasn’t fond of (it sometimes felt like I was watching a bunch of trailers put together) but all in all I thought it was a great movie.

    Great review!!

  • Reply

    Ha. you forgot to mention that you got your copy free… because apparently the geofish guys still don’t have the whole processing order thing down.

    good review I agree.

    I think this is a better video example….

    • Reply

      Well… yes, there is that.

      In my view, though, being free only makes this movie a gift of the universe.

      If I’d have paid for it I would have been equally thankful… in fact, probably more so since I’d have thought, “Holy Crap, I’ve finally found a fly fishing adventure movie that doesn’t totally suck and make me wish I had the last hour of my life back (and the 20 buck it cost me… plus shipping… plus the electricity to play it… plus wear-and-tear on my laptop’s disc drive… plus the money I didn’t make doing something constructive and value-adding to the world).”


    • Reply

      Also, your video is pretty dang hilarious–all the more so for the long-ish lead up to the conclusion.

      • Padre

        thanks bud. I did at least get the “hook up”

        I agree with the geofish. Normally I just put in a fishing video as background sound for tieing flies but its hard to do with geofish.

  • Reply

    Couldn’t agree more about “In Search of a Rising Tide”. I return to it again and again and it’s pretty much the only one in the collection that stands up to repeated viewing. The art of storytelling is key – not GoPros and stupid soundtracks…

    • Reply

      Truer words never spoken. However, I must say that it’s not really the GoPro’s fault. It’s simply the lack of creativity (and editing) that makes them so poor. For example, this video here: was shot strictly on the GoPro, and while the story isn’t spectacular, I think it is pretty fun. (Of course, I shot it so I would!)

      BTW Nice site.

Leave Your Comment

© 2009-2018 Davin Ebanks All Rights Reserved -- Copyright notice by Blog Copyright